|
|
|
|
|
Home
»
Visual C#
»
Difference between Composition and Aggregation
|
|
|
|
Total page views :
66779
|
|
Total downloads :
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Similar ArticlesMost ReadTop RatedLatest
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Introduction:
Apart from programming, a lot of my spare time sat at the computer is spent reading group, blog postings, etc from other developers. One particular posting that caught my eye recently provoked a lot of response and mixed answers to a question posed by a poster. This question was, 'What is the difference between composition and aggregation and how would I express it in my programs'?
Reading the responses to the post, I had a mixed reaction, many of the responses reflected my understanding of the difference, others turned my understanding right around and explained composition as my understanding of aggregation.
This short article will put forward my understanding of composition and aggregation and how I would express it in C# code.
Composition:
As we know, inheritance gives us an 'is-a' relationship. To make the understanding of composition easier, we can say that composition gives us a 'part-of' relationship. Composition is shown on a UML diagram as a filled diamond (see Figure 1).

If we were going to model a car, it would make sense to say that an engine is part-of a car. Within composition, the lifetime of the part (Engine) is managed by the whole (Car), in other words, when Car is destroyed, Engine is destroyed along with it. So how do we express this in C#?
public class Engine { . . . }
public class Car
{
Engine e = new Engine();
.......
}
As you can see in the example code above, Car manages the lifetime of Engine.
Aggregation:
If inheritance gives us 'is-a' and composition gives us 'part-of', we could argue that aggregation gives us a 'has-a' relationship. Within aggregation, the lifetime of the part is not managed by the whole. To make this clearer, we need an example. For the past 12+ months I have been involved with the implementation of a CRM system, so I am going to use part of this as an example.
The CRM system has a database of customers and a separate database that holds all addresses within a geographic area. Aggregation would make sense in this situation, as a Customer 'has-a' Address. It wouldn't make sense to say that an Address is 'part-of' the Customer, because it isn't. Consider it this way, if the customer ceases to exist, does the address? I would argue that it does not cease to exist. Aggregation is shown on a UML diagram as an unfilled diamond (see Figure 2).

So how do we express the concept of aggregation in C#? Well, it's a little different to composition. Consider the following code:
public class Address { . . . }
public class Person
{
private Address address;
public Person(Address address)
{
this.address = address;
}
. . .
}
Person would then be used as follows:
Address address = new Address(); Person person = new Person(address);
or
Person person = new Person( new Address() );
As you can see, Person does not manage the lifetime of Address. If Person is destroyed, the Address still exists. This scenario does map quite nicely to the real world.
Conclusion:
As I said at the beginning of the article, this is my take on composition and aggregation. Making the decision on whether to use composition or aggregation should not be a tricky. When object modelling, it should be a matter of saying is this 'part-of' or does it 'have-a'?
|
|
|
Login
to add your contents and source code to this article
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Phil Curnow
Phil is a programmer with 15 years professional experience. He currently works for a Local Authority in the United Kingdom. His programming language of choice is C#, but over the years he has used many languages within his work. His web site and blog can be found at http://www.curnow.biz
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
C# Consulting is founded in 2002 by the founders of C# Corner. Unlike a traditional
consulting company, our consultants are well-known experts in .NET and many of them
are MVPs, authors, and trainers. We specialize in Microsoft .NET development and
utilize Agile Development and Extreme Programming practices to provide fast pace
quick turnaround results. Our software development model is a mix of Agile Development,
traditional SDLC, and Waterfall models.
|
|
Click here to learn more about C# Consulting. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Introducing MaxV - one click. infinite control. Hyper-V Hosting from MaximumASP.
Finally – a virtual platform that delivers next-generation Windows Server 2008 Hyper-V virtualization technology from a managed hosting partner you can truly depend on. Visit www.maximumasp.com/max for a FREE 30 day trial. Hurry offer ends soon.
Climb aboard the MaxV platform and take advantage of High Availability, Intelligent Monitoring, Recurrent Backups, and Scalability – with no hassle or hidden fees.
As a managed hosting partner focused solely on Microsoft technologies since 2000, MaximumASP is uniquely qualified to provide the superior support that our business is built on. Unparalleled expertise with Microsoft technologies lead to working directly with Microsoft as first to offer IIS 7 and SQL 2008 betas in a hosted environment; partnering in the Go Live Program for Hyper-V; and product co-launches built on WS 2008 with Hyper-V technology.
|
Dynamic PDF
ceTE software specializes in components for dynamic PDF generation and manipulation. The DynamicPDF™ product line allows you to dynamically generate PDF documents, merge PDF documents and new content to existing PDF documents from within your applications.
|
Go.NET
Build custom interactive diagrams, network, workflow editors, flowcharts, or software design tools. Includes many predefined kinds of nodes, links, and basic shapes. Supports layers, scrolling, zooming, selection, drag-and-drop, clipboard, in-place editing, tooltips, grids, printing, overview window, palette. 100% implemented in C# as a managed .NET Control. Document/View/Tool architecture with many properties&events. Optional automatic layout.
|
Dundas Software
Dundas Chart for .NET is the most advanced .NET charting package available today. With an extremely complete feature set, elegant architecture and easy implementation, Dundas Chart can quickly add advanced Charting functionality to enhance and transform ASP.NET and Windows Forms applications. Whether you are implementing charting into internal projects, or building applications for clients, Dundas Chart offers advanced technology and advanced results to get the most out of data.
|
60 FREE UI Controls from DevExpress
Register for your FREE copy on over 60 free presentation controls from
DevExpress - Absolutely Free-of-Charge without any royalties or distribution
costs. Visit Devexpress.com/60 today. Free controls include advanced lists box, dropdown calendar, rich text edit, spin
edit, tab control and so much more!
DevExpress engineers feature rich presentation controls and reporting tools for WinForms, ASP.NET, WPF, and Silverlight. Our technologies help you build your best, see complex software with greater clarity and deliver compelling business solutions for Windows and the web in the shortest possible time.
|
Clickatell's SMS Gateway
Clickatell's Developer Solutions allow you to SMS enable any website or
application via a range of API's. Learn More about our API connections.
|
Microsoft Visual Studio 2010
Visualize your workspace with new multiple monitor support, powerful Web development, new SharePoint support with tons of templates and Web parts, and more accurate targeting of any version of the .NET Framework. Get set to unleash your creativity.
|
Nevron Chart for .NET 2010.1 Now Available
The leading .NET charting control now features PDF, Flash and Silverlight export, visualization of large datasets and more. Deliver true charting functionality to your BI, Scorecard, Presentation or Scientific apps. Download evaluation now.
|
Developer-Ready ASP.NET 2.0 Web Hosting with 3 MONTHS FREE
Now supporting .NET 3.0 Framework with Windows Workflow Foundation, Windows Communication Foundation (WCF), Windows Presentation Foundation (WPF), windows CardSpace (WCS)! Providing more flexibility for Developers with Web Services Support and a User/Permission Manger. Also supporting MS SQL 2005/2000 with Real-Time Backups, FREE Automated Attach .MDF Tool, FREE SQL Restore and Shrink SQL DB Tools, and SQL
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|