Are we suppose to do peoples homework and deliver?

Suvendu Shekhar Giri

I am seeing people are asking to build the complete query or set of queries or small projects and surprisingly people are replying back with complete solutions/queries etc.

Just want to understand if that is acceptable?

How those solutions going to those people who don't understand anything?

It's surprising for me atleast, coming from stackoverflow and codeproject forums.

Can you make some guidlines for peoples answering questions or I am just wrong these things?

Example: http://www.c-sharpcorner.com/Forums/print-pyramid-in-sqlserver

7 Replies

Know the answer? Post it — somebody with the same question will find it here.

Suvendu Shekhar Giri9y ago
Thanks @Sameer. I am bit relieved to know that at least 1 member could understand my intention.

For rest of all, I am not here to prove anyone wrong or right. I just wanted to say that we should help people but not blindly which actually helps them for once but keeps them uneducated about the topic and when next time he/she gets a problem, he/she again comes back to with same question. Try to undertsand, let's help them in such a way that they will be able to solve their problems themeselves, most of the times.

Now think about our school days, if all of our homework would have been just copy-paste job, would we be now able to answer question of those guys?

I am not comparing C# Corner with any of the forums but there is nothing bad in adapting to something good. In fact, I am seeing C# Corner as the potential world leader in coming future. But, it's our resposiblity to maintain the quality of posts we put here so that we can proudly say, we helped peoples.

Once again, I understand, different opinions can be seen on this and I can be totally wrong on what I already have said in this thread.

Hope, you guys understand my points.

Thanks :)
0
Sameer Shaik9y ago
I agree with Suvendu Shekhar Giri.

Few guys really dont even tryng to get their solution from google.
Simply they posting their entire questions. They want readymade solution.

If you observe few questions, they are being asked again and again instead of having dozens of artciles/solutions for the same.

Because of this, Few questions may irrirate someone, and few answers may irritate some other.

And the quality of site also goes down, if users asking the same questions again and again, just increasing the number of threads. And there is no worth of answering such questions and gaining points.
+1
Jyoti Jodha9y ago
Thanx
@Suvendu Shekhar Giri Sir....

And we don’t want to c-sharpcorner like Codeproject and stackoverflow

If c-sharpcorner like this

Then
what is different in c-sharpcorner and Codeproject , stackoverflow.....???

We like c-sharpcorner jo jesa h wo hamare liye Best h...

Or Best hi rahega.....

+2
Suvendu Shekhar Giri9y ago
Well, I am doing so because that's what we do in in Codeproject and stackoverflow. As I said, I can be completely wrong and it indeed seems I am wrong but I think we should not help those who haven't tried anything. Anyway, I will not post such things like "what have you tried so far" etc. if those makes you irritating. Really sorry for that. Will talk to c# corner admins to understand the exact purpose of this forum. It doesn't makes sense to say correct if a large number of peoples doing wrong. And if it is correct, then people like me should say sorry and bid bye forever. Sorry for making you all irritating all these days. I could never make anyone understand, what exactly was my intention.
-1
Jyoti Jodha9y ago
@Suvendu Shekhar Giri
But your all answer are out of topic

And sorry for this, your all answer are IRRITATE

And your all answer are same

Like this

“This is not right place” etc

Dekho bhai

· 2,264,514 users have contributed to 115,978threads and 366,359 posts.

Itne user h kise ko problem nhi hue aap ko hi kyu hue.....???

0
Suvendu Shekhar Giri9y ago
Dear @Dharmraj,
Sorry, this was not for you. I gave just as an example. There are many such occurence.
I am not sure if this allowed here as this is strictly not allowed in CodeProject and StackOverflow. These types of questions are going through because all these things are managed by C# corner admin panel peoples but in case of StackOverflow and CodeProject, people with more reputation/points do the moderation and report them as "Not Question" and hence deleted from queue.

Now situation is like, when you say someone that we can't build a complete project for you they are getting angry and replying back with harsh words. Not sure where we are heading to by helping them in such a way.
Example : http://www.c-sharpcorner.com/forums/one-request-for-a-small-angular-project

This question was for people who moderate/manage forum for c# corner.

Thanks anyway for understanding. Really appreciate it.
0
Dharmraj Thakur9y ago
You are right @SUVENDU SHEKHAR GIRI sir... It was easy for me thats why I have provided that solution.

I accept, I have to explain whole thing or provide way to solution.

I really sorry for this to whole community, I'll take care. Thank You
+4